The Legal Intelligencer profiled a recent opinion in response to a motion for redeposition filed by Carol Nelson Shepherd and Patricia M. Giordano in the case of Karim v. Reedy. The recent opinion requires the defendant obstetrician and nurse be redeposed to answer questions their counsel had previously instructed them not to, claiming their opinions couldn’t be discovered without their consent. The decision, filed in Lackawanna County, has a broad impact on both plaintiffs and defendants seeking to question doctors about patient care.